![]() |
The
Baal Shem Tov, or Besht — the founder of Chasidism —
|
|
Hu Ya'aneinu (fathers and mothers) for Yom Kippur Eve and Selichot pdfIt's hard to imagine that we've been saying the prayer-piyut Hu Ya'aneinu, "The One will answer us", for so many centuries, without mentioning Sarah, Deborah, Ruth, and so many other heroic women. This version of the prayer includes verses for both the women and the men of our Jewish story, in appropriate liturgical Hebrew. The first version of this egal Hu Ya'aneinu was written in 1995 by Mark Frydenberg and myself; it's been updated in numerous ways. See especially the verse about Rachel, which is recast in messianic terms. While some traditional verses about the men have been left out to make space for the new verses, I carved out space to put Elijah back in. (Needless to say, feel free to add the rest as well as to add new women in your own version.) Other egalitarian versions of Hu Ya'aneinu can be found on Ritualwell. Download/view the pdf or the Davka file of Hu Ya'aneinu!Here's the English: The One who answered Abraham our father on Mount Moriah, Hu ya'aneinu. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Very good except the ending. In both this version and that of the traditional piyut the inference is that all of those mentioned were "righteous, devout and pure." An examination of the lives of at least some of these would prove quite the contrary. Perhaps they should be noted for their courage of leadership, the ability to endure hardship while working for Kidush Hashem, and for the benefit of Amcha. They had foibles, weaknesses, as do the rest of us. The end of the last sentence seems to attempt to somewhat deal with this issue as it concludes with "as this moment needs". This make the sentence ambiguous. Why not clarify it and take a stand? Posted by: Danel Jezer at October 10, 2008 5:25 PM |
|
Design in progress © Rabbi David Mevorach Seidenberg 2006 |